Baraka sues Alina Habba, DHS Agent for false arrest and defamation

In a stunning legal move with national implications, Newark Mayor Ras Baraka filed a federal lawsuit on June 3, 2025, against Alina Habba—Donald Trump’s former personal attorney now serving as interim U.S. Attorney for New Jersey—and DHS Special Agent Ricky Patel. Filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey, the complaint alleges false arrest, malicious prosecution, and defamation connected to Baraka’s May 9 arrest outside the Delaney Hall ICE facility.

The 17-page complaint accuses Habba and Patel of orchestrating a violent, unlawful arrest to publicly humiliate Baraka during a peaceful visit to the facility, operated by the private prison contractor GEO Group. According to the lawsuit, Baraka had been invited onto the property by a GEO employee and complied when DHS Agent Patel asked him to leave. Nonetheless, just five minutes later, at least 20 armed and masked DHS agents “descended on the Mayor and members of Congress,” violently arresting Baraka and shoving his security detail.

The complaint alleges that Patel ordered agents to “take him down,” a phrase reportedly captured on video evidence, which led to Baraka being thrown to the ground and handcuffed behind his back in what the lawsuit calls a calculated effort to “effect maximum humiliation.”

Baraka, who has publicly criticized anti-immigration policies and is seen as a rising star in Democratic politics, said the incident was more than political retaliation—it was a constitutional violation.

“This wasn’t law enforcement. This was political theater—violent, targeted, and unlawful,” Baraka said in a statement through his attorney, Nancy Erika Smith of Smith Mullin P.C. “If this can happen to an elected mayor during a peaceful visit, it can happen to any American.”

Attorney Smith emphasized the broader political context: “This administration is clearly targeting Democratic officials. Mayor Baraka is standing up to government agents who abuse their power.”

The lawsuit directly cites a social media post by Habba on the platform X, owned by Elon Musk, where—before Baraka had even been formally charged—she declared, “NO ONE IS ABOVE THE LAW.” The complaint claims this post, along with others, served to defame the Mayor and promote a politically motivated narrative to “turn New Jersey red,” quoting Habba as allegedly saying she hoped to do so “while I’m [interim US Attorney].”

Magistrate Judge André Espinosa dismissed the trespassing charges just 13 days after the arrest, calling it a “worrisome misstep” and stating that “an arrest, particularly of a public figure, is not a preliminary investigative tool… it is a severe action… and should only be undertaken after a thorough, dispassionate evaluation of credible evidence.”

The lawsuit also details the trauma experienced by Baraka and his team, alleging that the conduct of Patel and DHS agents was not only unlawful but intended to silence and intimidate. It includes photographic and video evidence of the incident and notes that Baraka never resisted and left the property promptly when asked.

This lawsuit emerges as Baraka is rumored to be exploring a run for governor of New Jersey in 2025. His supporters see the case as a flashpoint in the broader national debate over the politicization of federal law enforcement and immigrant detention practices.

As of press time, Habba has not filed a formal response to the complaint. A spokesperson for DHS declined to comment, citing ongoing litigation.

The case is Baraka v. Habba and Patel, U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey, Case No. 2:25-cv-06846.

DONATE